Daniel 9 and the Seven-Year Tribulation: My Study Notes

4–6 minutes

read

Try something with me. Open Daniel 9 and put your finger on the verse that gives the tribulation its seven years. If you landed on verse 27, keep your finger there. Who is the “he” at the start of that verse? What made you picture that particular person?

That little pronoun is where a lot of the weight sits. I read it as a reference to Jesus. Friends of mine read it as a future ruler who turns on Israel. Here’s why I land where I do, and the objection I’d want somebody to raise if we were sitting across the table with our Bibles open. Read Daniel 9 in the ESV.

Start where Daniel starts

Before Daniel ever hears about seventy weeks, he’s reading Jeremiah. Jerusalem lies in ruins. Daniel understands Jeremiah to have spoken of seventy years, and his response is to pray. Look at the pronouns in verses 4–19. Daniel keeps saying we. He confesses his people’s sin and asks God to show mercy to the city that bears his name.

Now read Gabriel’s answer in verse 24. Sin, atonement, and righteousness are right there alongside the future of Jerusalem. That matters to me. An interpretation can account for every date on a chart and still owe Daniel an answer to his prayer.

Watch part one · Where do the seven years come from?

Watch “What If There Is No 7 Year Tribulation?” on YouTube

The usual calculation treats each “week” as a group of seven years. Seventy groups give you 490 years. The passage mentions seven weeks, sixty-two weeks, and one final week. On that reading, the last week gives you seven years. So I understand where the number comes from. The question is what places those seven years in our future.

Thomas Ice makes a serious case for an interval. Verse 26 puts the death of an anointed figure after the sixty-two weeks that follow the first seven. It also describes the destruction of the city and sanctuary. If those events fall between the sixty-ninth and seventieth weeks, the final week can still lie ahead. My question is whether “after” tells us that the clock stops. Something that happens during the next week also happens after the previous one. The wording leaves us with a decision that arithmetic alone can’t make. Read Ice’s argument for the gap.

Watch part two · Who makes the covenant?

Watch “Is Daniel 9 About Jesus or the Antichrist?” on YouTube

Try reading verses 26 and 27 twice. First, take the covenant-maker in verse 27 to be the coming prince mentioned near the end of verse 26. That gives the futurist reading a real foothold. Now try pairing the anointed figure’s death in verse 26 with the covenant and sacrifice in verse 27, and pairing the two descriptions of destruction. In that arrangement verse 27 revisits the events of verse 26. Mitchell Chase develops this reading. Read Chase’s explanation.

What draws me to that second reading is what Jesus says over the cup. In Matthew 26:28 he connects his covenant blood, the many, and forgiveness. Then Hebrews 10 asks what repeated offerings could accomplish and what changed when Christ offered himself. Read those passages together and I can see an answer to the man who was praying for mercy at the beginning of Daniel 9. Matthew 26:26–29 · Hebrews 10:10–18.

The hardest objection for my reading

If Jesus ended sacrifice at the cross, why did priests keep offering sacrifices afterward? They did. Josephus records that the daily offering failed during the Roman siege of Jerusalem in AD 70 because there was nobody to offer it. A person standing at the temple the week after the crucifixion would still have seen priests at work. Josephus, Jewish War 6.94.

John Walvoord presses exactly that point. Hebrews can establish that Christ’s sacrifice is sufficient while leaving open what Daniel meant by the cessation of offerings. If Daniel is describing a ruler physically shutting down worship, the cross doesn’t fit that detail on its own. Read Walvoord’s argument.

My answer turns on what an offering is supposed to do. Hebrews 10 grounds forgiveness in Jesus’ completed offering. That’s the sense in which I understand the cross to end sacrifice for sin. The altar’s operations ended later. Josephus helps date the interruption. Identifying the cross as the fulfillment is my theological reading. I also wouldn’t use AD 70 as though it fell neatly three and a half years after the crucifixion. It didn’t.

One more reading worth knowing

There’s also an older historical setting to consider. The notes to the New American Bible identify the anointed figure in verse 26 with the murdered high priest Onias III and read verse 27 against Antiochus IV’s suppression of temple worship in the second century BC. That reading gives the interruption of sacrifices a concrete setting. It also raises a good question for Christians reading Matthew 24:15: how does Jesus take up Daniel’s language again for his own hearers? Read the USCCB notes on Daniel 9:25–27 · Read Matthew 24:15–22.

What I take away from Daniel’s prayer

I believe Jesus will return, the dead will be raised, and God will judge the world. I don’t find that Daniel 9 requires a future seven-year tribulation. The part I keep coming back to is Daniel himself. He opens a prophecy, sees the condition of his people, and gets on his knees. I can spend an hour arguing about the last four verses and forget to do the thing Daniel did in the first place.

If we were studying this together, I’d want to hear your answer to one question: when you read verses 26 and 27 side by side, which detail most strongly shapes who you think makes the covenant?

Leave a Reply